1. Whereas
the labeling guidelines are presented by the EU as a purely
"technical measure" designed to protect European consumers, there is
no doubt that the main purpose of the measure is to exert political pressure
upon Israel. As the preparation of the labeling guidelines has been
pending for more than three years, the recent adoption begs the question why
the EU decided that it should be done now.
2. It is
intolerable that Israel is the only country that has been singled out by the
EU for such a policy, despite the fact that there are over 200 disputed
territories worldwide.
3. These
measures are discriminatory in nature and might be perceived as a trade
barrier.
4. It is
very surprising that in these times of extreme turmoil and instability in the
Middle East while Israel is targeted by a wave of terrorism, the EU finds it
appropriate to adopt highly political and controversial one-sided guidelines targeting
Israel, the only stable democracy in the region.
5. As a
matter of fact, the labeling guidelines initiative is being promoted by
anti-Israel organisations and not by European consumers-protection
organisations. The labeling guidelines might encourage the
idea that the boycott of Israeli products is acceptable, which contradicts
stated EU policies. It will also provide renewed energy to the BDS (Boycott,
Divestment and Sanctions) movement being advanced by certain NGO's.
6. The labeling
guidelines will negatively affect the relations between the EU and Israel.
Their adoption also raises concerns regarding the kind of role that the
EU will be able to play in the future with regard to the Israeli-Palestinian
peace process and the ability to view the EU as an honest and objective
facilitator.
7. The labeling
guidelines will not benefit the advocates of the two-states-for-two-peoples
solution. They constitute an attempt to pre-judge the outcome of future
negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians. Worse, they could serve as an
additional incentive for the PA to eschew direct negotiations with Israel.
8. Thousands
of Palestinian households will lose their main source of income due to
changes in production policy of Israeli companies deriving from these
guidelines. Currently, there are tens of thousands (approx. 30,000) of
Palestinians working for Israeli companies in the territories under Israeli
control since 1967.